Latest Mission Log
Latest Supplemental
Latest Live Show
Latest "Prodigy"
Latest "The Orville"
Episode
052
The Omega Glory
It’s the Stars and Stripes forever, even on a planet far, far away from Earth with no contact with Earth before. Who are the good guys? Who are the bad guys? This week, we put The Omega Glory in the Mission Log.
For some strange reason – this episode was used as a ViewMaster reel.
Maybe that’s how I should have watched it.
Maybe ?
Hey, I owned that!
Haven’t we seen the crazy character before?
Oh yeah – I almost forgot – they must have tried to erase Episode 10 from my mind !
I have to complement you gentlemen on how diplomatic you were with this episode, with what was basically physical evidence that, as a writer, Gene Roddenberry made for a terrific producer.
But I have to agree with you that, for all its scientific ludicrousness, and apparent racism, the episode has *some* merit. When I was growing up in the Bicentennial/Reagan Era, the overt patriotism appealed to me.
When I was older, and living outside the United States and seeing the world from a different perspective, I saw the seeming jingoism, the racism and hypocrisy in it – but also the *inversion* of the racism, where all the racist arguments you might hear about Asian peoples – they’re savage, unintelligible, inscrutable – was being applied to the blond white people in the story.
Now, living in an era where people believe that the freedoms they embrace and espouse allows them to take those same freedoms away from gays, Muslims, transgendered people, immigrants, the poor and others, I can’t totally dismiss this episode, for no other reason than Kirk’s speech when he sees their Constitution:
“That which you call Ee’d Plebnista, was not written for the chiefs of kings, or the warriors or the rich or the powerful, but for ALL the people!… These words and the words that follow, were not written only for the Yangs, but for the Kohms as well! They must apply to everyone, or they mean nothing!”
Not that I’m chomping at the bit to go and watch this again 🙂
Agreed – and people wonder how a 50 year old show can have relevance today…
I think if you are a Star Trek fan, then you have to love Arena, Gamesters of
Triskelion and this. You have to enjoy the failure of great ambition.
I think you guys are right that this was about 3 episodes shoved into one. I appreciate the ambition (and a plot-twist) but this remains one of my least favorite episodes. The biggest problem I had with it, to address to the racist undertones, is that the episode almost implied: “Let’s look at a world in which the white people are actually the ‘savages’ and the Asian society is the ‘civilized.'” Which kind of implies that in the real world, the opposite is true. That, combined with the some of the terminology thrown around, and the stereotyped appearances, made this episode really cringe-y to me. However, you totally sold me on the last part. I initially thought the end was a bit ham-fisted and preachy but the Kirk speech taken alone is really great.